Ethnohistory and etnicheskaia istoriia: outer similarities and inner differences

Cover Page

Cite item

Full Text

Open Access Open Access
Restricted Access Access granted
Restricted Access Subscription Access

Abstract

Soviet ethnic history (etnicheskaia istoriia) and North American ethnohistory share not only similar names but also similar methods, such as the collection of interdisciplinary sources and the synthesis of collected information by ethnographers/anthropologists. However, on the inside, differences substantially exceed similarities. Thus, the foundation of the Soviet research genre is a primordial understanding of ethnicity where the focus is the past of either indigenous groups or industrialized peoples, whereas the North American genre is principally concerned with the continuity of group identities. In these genres, disciplinary development crises were also handled differently: ethnohistorians, while occupying a rather marginal position within anthropology, nevertheless quite radically expanded the geographical and subject areas of their research, whereas in the works of ethnohistorians, on the contrary, the discussion of theoretical issues nearly ceased. This situation is due to the different modes of functioning of science and research scholarship in the respective societies, as well as different degrees of involvement in interactions with various levels of the governmental structure.

Full Text

Restricted Access

About the authors

Dmitriy V. Verkhovtsev

Institute of Ethnology and Anthropology, Russian Academy of Sciences

Author for correspondence.
Email: dverhovtcev@gmail.com

стажер-исследователь

Russian Federation, 32a Leninsky prospect, Moscow, 119991

References

  1. Abashin, S.A. 2018. “V labirintakh etnogeneza i etnicheskoi istorii”: trudy B.K. Karmyshevoi kak nasledie sovetskoi etnografii [“In the Labyrinths of Ethnogenesis and Ethnic History”: Works of B.K. Karmysheva as a Legacy of Soviet Ethnography]. In Oazisy Shelkovogo puti: sovremennye problemy etnografii, istorii i istochnikovedeniia narodov Tsentral’noi Azii [Oases of the Silk Road: Modern Problems of Ethnography, History and Source Studies of the Peoples of Central Asia], edited by R. Abbyasov, 34–45. Moscow: Islamskaia kniga.
  2. Abler, T.S. 1982. Ethnohistory: A Choice between Being Anthropology or Being Nothing. Central Issues in Anthropology 4 (1): 45–61.
  3. Aksenova, E.P., and M.A. Vasiliev. 1993. Problemy etnogonii slavianstva i ego vetvei v akademicheskikh diskussiiakh rubezha 1930–1940-kh godov [Problems of the Ethnogony of the Slavs and Its Branches in Academic Discussions at the Turn of the 1930s–1940s]. Slavianovedenie 2: 86–104.
  4. Alekseev, V.P. 1986. Etnogenez [Ethnogenesis]. Moscow: Vysshaia shkola.
  5. Alymov, S.S. 2017. Ukrainskie korni teorii etnosa [Ukrainian Roots of the Theory of Ethnos]. Etnograficheskoe obozrenie 5: 67–84.
  6. Alymov, S.S. 2021. “Imperialisticheskie razvedchiki” ili kollegi? Sovetsko-amerikanskii antropologicheskii dialog v period rannei kholodnoi voiny (konets 1940-kh – nachalo 1960-kh gg.) [“Imperialist Intelligence Officers” or Colleagues? Soviet-American Anthropological Dialogue during the Early Cold War (Late 1940s – Early 1960s)]. Sibirskie istoricheskie issledovaniia 1: 62–87.
  7. Anderson, D.G. 2007. Ethnohistory and Ethnic History: A Comparative Analysis of English and Russian Language Traditions of Writing the History of Indigenouse People. In Etnoistoriia i arkheologiia Severnoi Evrazii: teoriia, metodologiia i praktika issledovaniia [Ethnohistory and Archeology of Northern Eurasia: Theory, Methodology and Practice of Research], edited by A.V. Kharinskii, 581–583. Irkutsk: Izdatel’stvo IrGTU.
  8. Anfertiev, A.N. 1993. Prolegomeny k izucheniiu etnicheskoi istorii [Prolegomena to the Study of Ethnic History]. In Etnosy i etnicheskie protsessy. Pamiati R.F. Itsa [Ethnoses and Ethnic Processes: In Memory of R.F. Its], edited by V.A. Popov, 62–70. Moscow: Vostochnaia literatura.
  9. Arzyutov, D.V. 2021. Reassembling the Environmental Archives of the Cold War: Perspectives from the Russian North. PhD diss., KTH Royal Institute of Technology.
  10. Arzyutov, D.V., S.S. Alymov, and D.J. Anderson, eds. 2014. Ot klassikov k marksizmu: soveshchanie etnografov Moskvy i Leningrada (5–11 aprelia 1929 g.) [From the Classics to Marxism: Meeting of Ethnographers of Moscow and Leningrad (April 5–11, 1929)]. St. Petersburg: MAE RAN.
  11. Arzyutov, D., and K. Lukin. 2023. Introduction to “Entangled Indigenous Historicities from the Eurasian North”. Suomen Antropologi 47 (3): 9–17.
  12. Averkieva, Y.P. 1963. Sovremennye tendentsii v razvitii etnografii SShA [Modern Trends in the Development of Ethnography of the United States]. In Sovremennaia amerikanskaia etnografiia [Modern American Ethnography], edited by A.V. Efimov and Y.P. Averkieva, 19–21. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk SSSR.
  13. Averkieva, Y.P. 1971. Etnografiia i kul’turnaia/sotsial’naia antropologiia na Zapade [Ethnography and Cultural/Social Anthropology in the West]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 5: 9–16.
  14. Chaves, K.K. 2008. Ethnohistory: From Inception to Postmodernism and Beyond. The Historian 70 (3): 486–513.
  15. Dirks, N. 1988. The Hollow Crown: Ethnohistory of an Indian Kingdom. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  16. Eriksen, T.H. 2010. Ethicity and Nationalism: Anthropological Perspectives. London: PlutoPress.
  17. Gadlo, A.V. 1979. Etnicheskaia istoriia Severnogo Kavkaza IV–X vv. [Ethnic History of the Noth Caucasus 4–10 Centures] Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo Leningradskogo universiteta.
  18. Gumilev, L.N. 2008. Ot Rusi do Rossii [From Rus’ to Russia]. Moscow: AST; Khranitel’.
  19. Karachkova, E.Y. 2013. Dialogi s proshlym: etnoistoriia Radzhputskogo kniazhestva [Dialogues with the Past: Ethnohistory of the Rajput Principality]. Moscow: Sovpadenie.
  20. Khomich, L.V. 1974. Sootnoshenie poniatii “etnogenez” i “etnicheskaia istoriia” (na primere formirovaniia nenetskoi narodnosti) [The Relationship between the Concepts of “Ethnogenesis” and “Ethnic History” (Using the Example of the Formation of the Nenets People)]. In Kratkoe soderzhanie dokladov godichnoi nauchnoi sessii Instituta etnografii AN SSSR 1972–1973 gg. [Summary of Reports of the Annual Scientific Session of the Institute of Ethnography of the USSR Academy of Sciences in 1972–1973], edited by B.N. Putilov, L.M. Saburova, A.M. Reshetov, and K.V. Chistov, 61–65. Leningrad: Nauka.
  21. Kisser, T.S. 2019. Nemtsy Urala: etnoistoriia i identichnost’ [Germans of the Urals: Ethnohistory and Identity]. St. Petersburg: MAE RAN.
  22. Koropchevskii, D.A. 1905. Znachenie “geograficheskikh provintsii” v etnogenicheskom protsesse [The Meaning of “Geographical Provinces” in the Ethnogenic Process]. St. Petersburg: Slovo.
  23. Kozlov, S.Y., and P.I. Puchkov, eds. 1995. Blagodarim sud’bu za vstrechu s nim (o Tokareve S.A. – uchenom i cheloveke) [We Thank Fate for Meeting Him (About Tokarev S.A. – Scientist and Person)]. Moscow: IEA RAN.
  24. Kriukov, M.V. 1988. Etnicheskaia istoriia [Ethnic History]. In Svod etnograficheskikh terminov i poniatii [A Collection of Ethnographic Terms and Concepts]. Vyp. 2, Etnografiia i smezhnye distsipliny. Etnograficheskie subdistsipliny. Shkoly i napravleniia. Metody [Ethnography and Related Disciplines; Ethnographic Subdisciplines; Schools and Directions; Methods], edited by M.V. Kriukov and I. Zelnov, 58–59. Moscow: Nauka.
  25. Kuzeev, R.G. 1974. Proiskhozhdenie bashkirskogo naroda: etnicheskii sostav, istoriia rasseleniia [Origin of the Bashkir People: Ethnic Composition, History of Settlement]. Moscow: Nauka.
  26. Lurie, N.O. 1961. Ethnohistory: An Ethnological Point of View. Ethnohistory 8 (1): 78–92.
  27. Mikhankova, V.A. 1949. Nikolai Yakovlevich Marr. Ocherk ego zhizni i nauchnoi deiatel’nosti [Nikolai Yakovlevich Marr: Essay on His Life and Scientific Activities]. Moscow; Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk SSSR.
  28. Mironova, N.P., and V.V. Karlov. 2019. L.P. Lashuk: ot etnicheskoi istorii k istoricheskoi sotsiologii [L.P. Lashuk: From Ethnic History to Historical Sociology]. Izvestiia Komi nauchnogo tsentra UrO RAN (Syktyvkar) 4 (40): 72–80.
  29. Riehm, E.G., et al. 2019. What Is Ethnohistory?: A Sixty-Year Retrospective. Ethnohistory 1 (66): 145–162. https://doi.org/10.1215/00141801-7217401
  30. Sedov, V.V. 2006. Etnogenez rannikh slavian [Ethnogenesis of the Early Slavs]. Rusin 1 (3): 175–198.
  31. Shnirelman, V.A. 1993. Zlokliucheniia odnoi nauki: etnogeneticheskie issledovaniia i stalinskaia natsional’naia politika [The Misadventures of One Science: Ethnogenetic Research and Stalin’s National Policy]. Etnograficheskoe obozrenie 3: 52–68.
  32. Shnirelman, V.A. 2003. Etnogenez i identichnost’: natsionalisticheskie mifologii v sovremennoi Rossii [Ethnogenesis and Identity: Nationalist Mythologies in Modern Russia]. Etnograficheskoe obozrenie 4: 3–14.
  33. Shnirelman, V.A. 2006. Byt’ alanami. Intellektualy i politika na Severnom Kavkaze v XX veke [To Be Alans: Intellectuals and Politics in the North Caucasus in the 20 Century]. Moscow: NLO, 2006.
  34. Smith, A.D. 1988. Ethnic Origins of Nations. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
  35. Strong, P.T. 2015. Ethnohistory. In International Encyclopedia of the Social and Behavioral Sciences, edited by J.D. Wright, 8: 192–197. New York: Elsevier.
  36. Sukhorukova, O.A. 2020. Etnicheskaia i natsional’naia istoriia Rossii s drevneishikh vremen do XVII v.: uchebnoe posobie [Ethnic and National History of Russia from Ancient Times to the 17th Century]. Moscow: KNORUS.
  37. Tishkov, V.A. 2016. Ot etnosa k etnichnosti i posle [From Ethnos to Ethnicity and After]. Etnograficheskoe obozrenie 5: 5–22.
  38. Tokarev, S.A. 1949. K postanovke problem etnogeneza [Towards the Formulation of Problems of Ethnogenesis]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 3: 12–36.
  39. Tolstov, S.P. 1947. Sovetskaia shkola v etnografii [Soviet School in Ethnography]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 4: 8–28.
  40. Tomilov, N.A. 2016. Etnicheskaia istoriia kak napravlenie v otechestvennoi nauke 1970–1990-kh godov [Ethnic History as a Direction in Russian Science in the 1970s–1990s]. Vestnik Omskogo universiteta. Seriia, Istoricheskie nauki 3 (11): 43–58.
  41. Trubachev, O.N. 2003. Etnogenez i kul’tura drevneishikh slavian. Lingvisticheskie issledovaniia [Ethnogenesis and Culture of the Ancient Slavs: Linguistic Research]. Moscow: Nauka.
  42. Van-Stoun, D.U. 1981. Etnoistoricheskie issledovaniia na Aliaske: obzor [Ethnohistorical Research in Alaska: An Overview]. In Traditsionnye kul’tury Severnoi Sibiri i Severnoi Ameriki [Traditional Cultures of North Siberia and North America], edited by I.S. Gurvich, 212–228. Moscow: Nauka.
  43. Vasiliev, V.I. 1977. Problemy etnogeneza i etnicheskoi istorii narodov Severa [Problems of Ethnogenesis and Ethnic History of the Peoples of the North]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 4: 3–17.
  44. Verkhovtsev, D.V., and S.S. Petriashin. 2021. Teorii etnosa vs marksizm: istoriia mimeticheskogo soprotivleniia [Theories of Ethnos vs Marxism: The History of Mimetic Resistance]. Kunstkamera 1 (11): 88–104. https://doi.org/10.31250/2618-8619-2021-1(11)-88-104
  45. Verkhovtsev, D.V. 2022. Etnos post-mortem: sovetskie teorii etnosa v sovremennom russkoiazychnom diskurse [Ethnos Post-Mortem: Soviet Theories of Ethnos in Present Day Russian-Language Discourses]. Etnograficheskoe obozrenie 6: 79–101. https://doi.org/10.31857/S0869541522060069
  46. Veselkin, E.A. 1988. Etnoistoriia [Ethnohistory]. In Svod etnograficheskikh poniatii i terminov [A Collection of Ethnographic Terms and Concepts]. Vyp. 2, Etnografiia i smezhnye distsipliny. Etnograficheskie subdistsipliny. Shkoly i napravleniia. Metody [Ethnography and Related Disciplines; Ethnographic Subdisciplines; Schools and Directions; Methods], edited by M.V. Kriukov and I. Zelnov, 170–171. Moscow: Nauka.
  47. Volkova, N.G. 1985. Etnicheskaia istoriia: soderzhanie poniatiia [Ethnic History: Content of the Concept]. Sovetskaia etnografiia 5: 16–25.
  48. Yarzutkina, A.A. 2016. Raz’ezdnaia torgovlia russkikh kuptsov krainego severo-vostoka Rossii: etnoistoricheskii vzgliad [Traveling Trade of Russian Merchants in the Extreme Northeast of Russia: An Ethnohistorical View]. Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta 406: 182–193.

Supplementary files

Supplementary Files
Action
1. JATS XML
Download
2. Fig. 1. References to the terms “ethnic history”, “ethnogenesis" and ethnohistory in texts (according to Google Books)

Download (120KB)
Indexing metadata
3. Fig. 2. References to the terms “ethnic history” and “ethnogenesis" in scientific papers (according to Google Scholar)

Download (106KB)
Indexing metadata

Copyright (c) 2024 Russian Academy of Sciences