Meritocracy in focus of scientific controversy: catholic church and italian intellectuals

Cover Page

Cite item

Full Text

Open Access Open Access
Restricted Access Access granted
Restricted Access Subscription Access

Abstract

The article deals with the analysis of the arguments used by Italian intellectuals, Church hierarchies, clergy representatives, professors of Catholic universities to explain their attitude to the idea of meritocracy, its prospects and restrictions. The fight against corruption and undeserved privileges is particularly relevant in today's Italy with its traditions of clientelism, nepotism and family ties. At the center of the scientific dispute there are two "sites": the Catholic University of Milan "Sacro Cuore" and the newspaper of the Italian episcopate "Avvenire." During the public discussions, views in defense and against the "merit society" were expressed and argued. Advocates of meritocracy believe that this model will make Italy more modern and competitive, will allow to build a fairer society. Opponents, on the contrary, consider this concept an ideological justification for inequality and a "direct antithesis of democracy." In the future, this situation can cause increased social tension, frustration and deep social pessimism. Catholic thinkers presented the theological examination of "meritocracy". They explained that the Church's moral teaching considers the principle of "retributive" or rewarding justice as unjust and dangerous. The author comes to the conclusion that the polarity of opinions is explained by the conflict of ideological, religious and worldview attitudes of Italian intellectuals, who are not ready to hear the arguments of the opposing side. The stance of the clergy on meritocracy can be explained in the light of the Church's magisterium on the common good, rights and dignity of the person.

About the authors

Veronika Evgen'evna Yazkova

Institute of Europe Russian Academy of Sciences

Email: yazkova@yandex.ru
Moscow, Russia

References

  1. Евлахов А.А. (2014) Государство и общество: от демократии XX века к меритократии XXI века. Материалы международной научно-практической конференции "Современные тенденции и механизмы консолидации государства, бизнеса, общества". Издательство Курского института менеджмента, экономики и бизнеса, Курск. С. 46-49.
  2. Козлов В.И. (2020) Понятие меритократии в современном философско-социологическом дискурсе. Миссия Конфессий. Т. 9. № 3 (44). С. 350-353.
  3. Канарш Г.Ю. (2021) Ролз и спор о меритократии. Человек. Т. 32. № 3. С. 116-124.
  4. Можайкина О.А. (2020) Меритократия есть позитивное или негативное устройство общества? Право как искусство добра и справедливости: сборник научных трудов Всероссийской научной конференции (1 октября 2020 года). Юго-Зап. гос. Ун-т, Курск. С. 287-289.
  5. Серов А.П. (2020) Концепция меритократии и ее роль в будущем человечества. Ratio et natura. № 1. URL: https://ratio-natura.ru/sites/default/files/2021-06/koncepciya-meritokratii-i-ee-rol-v-buduschem-chelovechestva.pdf (дата обращения: 17.12.2022).
  6. Boarelli M. (2011) L'inganno della meritocrazia. Lo straniero. 13.04. URL: https://diversamentestrutturati.noblogs.org/post/2011/04/13/linganno-della-meritocrazia-articolo-da-lo-straniero/(accessed: 13.01.2023).
  7. Bruni L. (2017) I tristi imperi del merito. Avvenire. 11.02. URL: https://www.avvenire.it/opinioni/pagine/luigino-bruni-sul-confine-e-oltre-4 (accessed: 17.01.2023).
  8. Bruni L. (2019) Mai col sangue dei figli. Avvenire. 26.10. URL: https://www.avvenire.it/opinioni/pagine/luigino-bruni-profezia-est-storia-21 (accessed: 17.01.2023).
  9. Bruni L., Santori P. (2021) La meritocrazia? Un'illusione che giustifica le diseguaglianze. Avvenire. 05.05. URL: https://www.avvenire.it/opinioni/pagine/la-meritocrazia-unillusione-che-giustifica-le-diseguaglianze (accessed: 13.01.2023).
  10. Pelligra V. (2021) E' illusione di un mondo giusto la trappola della meritocrazia. Avvenire. 14.05. URL: https://www.avvenire.it/opinioni/pagine/illusione-di-un-mondo-giusto-la-trappola-della-meritocrazia (accessed: 13.12.2022).
  11. Repole R. (2021) Il senso teologico del far fruttare i "doni" ricevuti. Avvenire. 12.06. URL: https://www.avvenire.it/opinioni/pagine/far-fruttare-i-doni-ricevuti-il-senso-teologico-del-merito (accessed: 17.01.2023).
  12. Zamagni S. (2022) Meritocrazia e meritorietà. The Fund Raising Scool. 27.02. URL: https://www.fundraisingschool.it
  13. Zanini R.I. (2011) Vinca il migliore e cosi sia. O no? Avvenire. 04.05. URL: https://www.avvenire.it/agora/pagine/dibattito-meritocrazia-lavoro-scuola_201105040843488070000 (accessed: 13.12.2022).

Supplementary files

Supplementary Files
Action
1. JATS XML

Copyright (c) 2023 Russian Academy of Sciences